It is important in decision-making, policy development, and the
establishment of new programs in Social Work that these initiatives
be supported by scientific evidence. Evidence-based practice is based
on evaluation research that highlights interventions that have been
found to be effective. Establishing the evidence-base involves either
consulting secondary reviews of studies or synthesizing the results
of
single studies.
This module covers the emerging area of evidence-based Social Work
with an emphasis on Children and Youth.
It provides an opportunity to gain
a comprehensive overview of concepts in best evidence, to understand
distinctions between evidence-based Medicine and evidence-based
Social
Work, to explore resources that provide evidence-based practice
information, and to develop techniques for searching and finding
research to support best evidence in the field of Children and Youth.
Because some areas of Social Work "research are descriptive and (lack) a
critical perspective...it may be difficult to find evaluative research on
outcomes of methods...Sources of Social Work knowledge are diverse, with
ogranizations, policy makers, professionals and users making valuable
contributions, alongside research." (Braye, S. & Preston-Shoot, M., 2007
p. 313-315). This module will try to deal with gaps and weaknesses in the
knowledge base when compared to health sciences, other kinds of
research to use if Randomized Control Trials and Systematic Reviews are not
available, and broader questions of values and ethics that also inform
practice in Social Work.
[Source: Braye, S. and Preston-Shoot, M. (2007). On systematic reviews in Social Work:
Observations from teaching, learning and assessment of law in social work education.
British Journal of Social Work 37 (313-334) ]
Implied in the graph below is a hierarchy of Research Methods, with
methodologies
in medicine considered at a higher level than methodologies in Social Sciences:
| |
Social Sciences |
Medicine |
Research Methodology |
|
Randomized
Control Trails |
Cross-sectional Surveys |
Clinical Trials |
Case Controlled Studies |
Meta-analysis |
Cohort Stiudies |
Systematic Review |
Literature Review |
[Source: Cournoyer, B. (2004). The evidence-based Social Work Skills Book.
Boston,Pearson/Allyn and Bacon.]